Playing in the second violins is different than playing in the firsts in ways that I will probably be digesting for a while. Most prominent in my mind after two rehearsals is that when playing in the seconds, it's harder for me to tell when I'm screwing up than it is when I'm playing with the firsts. There are so many ways to screw up musically--I seem to discover new ones all the time--but for now, I'll just focus on intonation when learning a new set of orchestra music.
With the firsts, it seems that you either have the melody, just had the melody, or will be getting the melody soon. When I'm so plugged into the melody, it's fairly obvious (even when sight reading) if I'm out of tune or overlooking an accidental or something. In saying this, I reveal the ugly truth that in the firsts, I didn't always listen as closely as I should have to what was happening elsewhere in the orchestra. Sometimes--OK, generally--those bits of resting and listening and accompaniment felt like interludes between the real business of diving into the fun, sexy melody. Oh, what an entitled, self-centered member of the firsts I was!
In the seconds it's not as obvious, at least when sight reading, if I am hitting wrong notes. The notes may not feel wrong because sight reading can be so disorienting that I lose my feel
for exactly where the notes are on the fingerboard, even in first
position. (Maybe this will improve as I get my orchestra chops back, but sight reading presents a major cognitive load for me right now.)
Listening to my stand partner and
section mates is obviously the biggest help. However, listening to myself while listening to others--either to match them or to figure out how my part meshes with theirs--is a balancing act. I'm finding it tough, maybe because I haven't played with an orchestra for so long. When I am practicing by myself, I can easily hear if, say, my A flat is in tune by listening for the interval to be right with the F natural that came before it. In a rehearsal, processing what I hear from others while hearing/assessing/correcting my own intonation is a lot tougher. On top of that, the music we're
rehearsing contains a couple of areas with divisi parts where there may
be only three other people in the section playing the same notes as me
at any given time, and only one sitting close enough for me to really
hear. It's just going to take a healthy amount of practice time on my own to get all of this that into my head and my fingers.
In tourism terms, I appreciate having seen some wonders of the world with the firsts but I look forward to traveling off the beaten path with the seconds. In looking for some validation of this viewpoint, I found this very interesting Los Angeles Times article about second violinists. In it are some words of inspiration about the role of the seconds from Dan Nobuhiko Smiley, principal second violinist in the San Francisco Symphony:
"It's a very thrilling
feeling to feel wired into this mega, gigantic string organism. It's not always
the most glamorous, but it's very heartfelt -- it's the soul of music-making at
that level," he says. "When you're playing the second violin part,
you can see the textures, the almost brocade-like tapestry."
That's the spirit!